Perth is clearly a happy hunting ground. Sir Carnegie has won 2 of his 5 races there, an impressive win rate of 40 percent at a single course. He also shows a marked preference for slightly soft ground, winning 2 of 5 races (40 percent) when conditions are damp rather than bone-dry. When trainer Mickey Bowen runs him in Class 5 races—the kind of lower-level competition that suits his profile—Sir Carnegie converts at 33 percent (2 wins from 6), a significantly better rate than his overall figures suggest. These are the sweet spots worth watching for.
Jockey Shane Fenelon, who has ridden Sir Carnegie twice, has won both times aboard him—a 100 percent record over two rides—though that sample is small. The real partnership to monitor is with Bowen's yard at Haverfordwest, which has been a powerhouse this season, turning out 52 winners. Bowen has indicated his horse is improving with every outing, building confidence and relaxing into his races, particularly over jumps. The trainer was bullish about Sir Carnegie's chances in a Newcastle race in late March, suggesting he saw something worth backing. For a horse hovering around the 19 percent mark, that kind of insider conviction is worth noting.
| Course | Races | Results | Last run | Win rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Perth Galloping |
5 | 2 wins, 1 second, 2 thirds | 24 Sep | 40% |
| Punchestown Galloping |
3 | 3 other | 3 May | 0% |
| Hexham Undulating |
2 | 1 win, 1 other | 6 Jun | 50% |
| Newcastle Galloping |
2 | 1 win, 1 other | 31 Mar | 50% |
| Kelso Undulating |
2 | 1 win, 1 second | 4 Oct | 50% |
| Market Rasen Sharp |
2 | 2 other | 18 Jul | 0% |
| Downpatrick Undulating |
2 | 2 other | 15 Jul | 0% |
| Down Royal Galloping |
2 | 1 third, 1 other | 13 Apr | 0% |
| Sligo Sharp |
1 | 1 other | 8 Aug | 0% |
| Listowel Sharp |
1 | 1 other | 31 May | 0% |
| Sedgefield Sharp |
1 | 1 second | 8 Oct | 0% |
| Kilbeggan Tight |
1 | 1 other | 25 Apr | 0% |
| Newton Abbot Sharp |
1 | 1 other | 22 Aug | 0% |
| Ballinrobe Sharp |
1 | 1 other | 23 Jul | 0% |
| Plumpton Sharp |
1 | 1 other | 21 Sep | 0% |