Chicago Critic
Chicago Critic has been treading water for over a year now. The five-year-old won for the last time back in May 2025 at Leopardstown, and since then has managed eight places from thirteen races—respectable enough on paper, but a long drought without crossing the line first. His recent form tells the story: across his last six outings, he has finished fourth, fourth, sixth, eighth, fourth, and sixth again. It is the sort of run that tests a horse's the yard and raises questions about whether better days are behind him.Based on TrackLab's analysis
Owner
Sam Mencoff & Tony Smurfit
📊 Key numbers
Career totals for this horse
🔍 Full analysis
Our model's view, based on this horse's career and recent runs
What makes Chicago Critic worth watching is what he showed earlier in his career. Ridden by Ben Coen, the pair have won together at a 19% rate—three wins from sixteen races—which suggests real partnership chemistry. More telling still is Chicago Critic's form at certain distances: over 1 mile 1 furlong to 1 mile 2 furlongs, he has won three of ten races, a 30% win rate that marks him out as a horse with clear preferences. Even more striking is his record at Naas: he has won twice from four races there, and his first career victory came at that track in October 2023. Naas clearly suits him, and with Ben Coen in the saddle, that combination is worth remembering when he next runs there.
Chicago Critic is trained by J P Murtagh at Coolaghknock Glebe in County Kildare, a yard that has sent out 53 winners this season and clearly knows how to get horses ready. With the horse still racing regularly and still capable of finding places, there is time yet for a return to the winner's circle—and when it comes, look for it at Naas, over his pet distance, with the jockey who brings out his best.
⚡ Strengths and risks
What helps this horse and what to watch out for
✓ What works in their favour
✔ Well suited by 1m1f – 1m2f distances: 30% win rate
⚠ What to watch out for
⚠ Poor record on good_to_yielding ground: 0 wins from 3 starts
⚠ Struggles on Galloping tracks: 0 wins from 5 starts
🎯 Where this horse runs best
Results split by ground, distance, race level and track shape
🌧 Ground
Good (a little give)
Likes
Yielding (slightly soft)
Unknown
Good to soft (some give)
Unknown
Soft to heavy (wet)
Unknown
Good to firm (fairly firm)
Unknown
Good to yielding (mild give)
Avoids
🏟 Track shape
Left-handed, long straights
Loves
Left-handed, hilly
Unknown
Right-handed, hilly
Unknown
Right-handed, long straights
Avoids
📅 Recent runs
The last 10 races, most recent first
6 Aug
6th
Leopardstown
1m1f – 1m2f · Good · 9 runners
27 Jun
4th
York
7f – 1m · Good · 6 runners
6 Jun
4th
Epsom Downs
7f – 1m · Good_To_Soft · 8 runners
23 May
8th
The Curragh
5f – 6½f · Good · 11 runners
6 Mar
4th
meydan
7f – 1m · Good · 15 runners
7 Feb
6th
abu_dhabi
1m1f – 1m2f · Good · 16 runners
23 Jan
2nd
meydan
7f – 1m · Good · 15 runners
2 Jan
6th
meydan
1m1f – 1m2f · Good · 10 runners
19 Dec
4th
meydan
1m1f – 1m2f · Yielding · 7 runners
13 Sep
7th
Leopardstown
1m1f – 1m2f · Good_To_Yielding · 10 runners
🏇 Jockeys
Every jockey who has ridden this horse, most rides first
🏟 Course record
Win rate at each course this horse has visited
| Course | Races | Results | Last run | Win rate |
| Leopardstown Galloping |
5 |
1 win, 1 third, 3 other |
6 Aug |
20% |
| Naas Galloping |
4 |
2 wins, 2 thirds |
19 May |
50% |
| meydan |
4 |
1 second, 3 other |
6 Mar |
0% |
| The Curragh Galloping |
2 |
2 other |
23 May |
0% |
| abu_dhabi |
1 |
1 other |
7 Feb |
0% |
| York Galloping |
1 |
1 other |
27 Jun |
0% |
| Epsom Downs Undulating |
1 |
1 other |
6 Jun |
0% |
| Cork Galloping |
1 |
1 other |
6 Apr |
0% |
| Goodwood Undulating |
1 |
1 other |
30 Jul |
0% |
| Tipperary Galloping |
1 |
1 other |
6 Oct |
0% |
| Ascot Galloping |
1 |
1 third |
22 Jun |
0% |